From: Effects of NAD+ precursor supplementation on glucose and lipid metabolism in humans: a meta-analysis
Study | Country | Study design | Population size | The basic characteristics Age, year BMI, kg/m2 | Intervention | Follow-up | Subgroup classification | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
T | C | T | C | ||||||
Liu, X.-Y. 2020 [9] | China | Parallel double blind | 49 | 49 | Age (T/C)55 ± 2/56 ± 2 | NAM 500–1500 mg/d | P | 52 weeks | (2) |
Conze, D. 2019 [1] | USA | Parallel double blind | 35 | 34 | Age (T/C)52.3 ± 5.9/50.7 ± 5.6 BMI (T/C)28 ± 2/28 ± 2 | NR 100 mg/d | P | 56 days | (1) |
Conze, D. 2019 [1] | USA | Parallel double blind | 35 | 34 | Age (T/C)50.2 ± 5.8/50.7 ± 5.6 BMI (T/C)28 ± 1/28 ± 2 | NR 300 mg/d | P | 56 days | (1) |
Conze, D/ 2019 [1] | USA | Parallel double blind | 35 | 34 | Age (T/C)50.9 ± 5.6/50.7 ± 5.6 BMI (T/C)28 ± 2/28 ± 2 | NR 1000 mg/d | P | 56 days | (1) |
Dollerup, O. 2019 [21] | Denmark | Parallel double blind | 20 | 20 | Age (T/C)58 ± 1.6/60 ± 2.0 BMI (T/C)32.4 ± 0.5/33.3 ± 0.6 | NR 2000 mg/d | P | 12 weeks | (6) |
Montastier, E. 2019 [23] | France | Parallel double blind | 11 | 11 | Patients are sedentary obese men Age (T/C)35.4 ± 2.2/35.4 ± 1.5 BMI (T/C)33.3 ± 0.7/32.6 ± 0.7 | ERN 2000 mg/d | P | 8 weeks | (6) |
Dollerup, O. 2018 [24] | Denmark | Parallel double blind | 20 | 20 | Age (T/C)58 ± 1.6/60 ± 2.0 BMI (T/C)32.4 ± 0.5/33.3 ± 0.6 | NR 2000 mg/d | P | 12 weeks | (1) |
Otvos, J. 2018 [25] | USA | Parallel double blind | 1367 | 1387 | Age (T/C)63.5 ± 8.8/63.8 ± 8.7 | Statin + ERN | P + Statin | 1 year | (5) |
Dellinger, R. W. 2017 [8] | Canada | Parallel double blind | 40 | 40 | Age 60–80 BMI 18–35 | NR 250 mg/d + PT 50 mg/d | P | 60 days | (1) |
Dellinger, R. W. 2017 [8] | Canada | Parallel double blind | 40 | 40 | Age 60–80 BMI 18–35 | NR 500 mg/d + PT 100 mg/d | P | 60 days | (1) |
Batuca, J. R. 2017 [26] | Portugal | Parallel double blind | 8 | 9 | Age (T/C)46.13 ± 12.02/52.44 ± 9.55 BMI (T/C) 28.09 ± 4.68/29.09 ± 3.2 | ERN 1500 mg/d | P | 12 weeks | (3) |
Goldberg, R. 2016 [27] | US Canada | Parallel | 423 | 410 | Patients with normal fasting glucose Age 62.9 ± 9.2 BMI 29.8 ± 5.0 | ERN 2000 mg/d + simvastatin 40 mg/d | P | 1 year | (1) |
Goldberg, R. 2016 [27] | US Canada | Parallel | 388 | 415 | Patients with impaired fasting glucose Age 63.2 ± 8.7 BMI 31.0 ± 4.8 | ERN 2000 mg/d + simvastatin 40 mg/d | P | 1 year | (4) |
Goldberg, R. 2016 [27] | US Canada | Parallel | 547 | 506 | Patients with diabetes Age 64.7 ± 8.3 BMI 32.6 ± 5.7 | ERN 2000 mg/d + simvastatin 40 mg/d | P | 1 year | (4) |
Zahed, N. S. 2016 [28] | Iran | Parallel double blind | 35 | 35 | Age (T/C) 49.8 ± 14.6/51.1 ± 14.1 | NA 100 mg/d | P | 8 weeks | (2) |
Savinova, O. 2015 [29] | USA | Parallel double blind | 14 | 14 | Patients with the Metabolic Syndrome Age (T/C)47.0 ± 11.3/49.6 ± 12.9 BMI (T/C)32.7 ± 4.6/29.8 ± 2.5 | ERN 2000 mg/d | P | 16 weeks | (6) |
Kalil, R. 2015 [30] | USA | Parallel double blind | 254 | 251 | Patients with chronic kidney disease Age (T/C)70.6 ± 7.2/70.8 ± 7.4 BMI (T/C)30.9 ± 5.4/30.4 ± 5.8 | ERN 2000 mg/d + Simvastatin 40 mg/d | P + Simvastatin 40 mg/d | 1 year | (2) |
Kalil, R. 2015 [30] | USA | Parallel double blind | 1464 | 1444 | Patients without chronic kidney disease Age 62.5 ± 8.4 | ERN 2000 mg/d + Simvastatin 40 mg/d | P + Simvastatin 40 mg/d | 1 year | (3) |
deGoma, E. 2015 [31] | USA | Parallel double blind | 5 | 3 | Patients with coronary artery disease Age 55 | niacin 6000 mg/d | P | 12 weeks | (5) |
Bregar, U. 2014 [32] | The Republic of Slovenia | Parallel double blind | 33 | 30 | Patients with coronary heart disease at least 6 months after myocardial infarction Mean age 52.5 years | niacin/laropiprant (1000/20 mg/d for 4 weeks and 2000/40 mg/d there after) All patients were treated with statins | P | 12 weeks | (5) |
Blond, E. 2014 [33] | France | cross-over Single blind | 20 | 20 | Age 46 ± 13 BMI (T/C)31.2 ± 2.2/31.1 ± 2.2 | ERN 2 000 mg/d | P | 8 weeks | (3) |
Aye, M. 2014 [34] | UK | Parallel double blind | 13 | 12 | Patients with Polycystic ovary syndrome Age (T/C)31.0 ± 6.33/31.7 ± 6.51 BMI (T/C)35.8 ± 5.55/34.8 ± 5.03 | niacin 1000 mg/d + laropiprant 20 mg/d | P | 12 weeks | (6) |
Philpott, A. 2013 [35] | Canada | Cross-over double blind | 66 | 66 | Patients with coronary heart disease Age 58 ± 8.5 BMI 29.9 ± 4.4 | ERN 1500 mg/d + atorvastatin 80 mg/d | P + atorvastatin 80 mg/d | 3 months | (5) |
Edalat-Nejad, M. 2012 [36] | Iran | cross-over double blind | 37 | 37 | Age 57 ± 11 years | Niacin 1000 mg/d | P | 8 weeks | (2) |
Ng, C. 2011 [37] | China | Parallel | 80 | 80 | Age (T/C) 58.34 ± 7.12/57.84 ± 8.48 | Niacin 1500 mg/d | P | 12 weeks | (3) |
Kim, S. 2011 [38] | Korea | Parallel double blind | 25 | 22 | Age (T/C) 57.4 ± 6.8/61.8 ± 8.3 | ERN 500 mg/d for first 4 weeks and ERN 1000 mg/d for the next 4 weeks | P | 8 weeks | (3) |
Boden, W. 2011 [39] | USA Canada | Parallel | 1561 | 1554 | Age (T/C) 63.7 ± 8.8/63.7 ± 8.7 | ERN 1500–2000 mg/d + Simvastatin 40–80 mg/d + Ezetimibe 10 mg/d | P + Simvastatin 40–80 mg/d + Ezetimibe 10 mg/d | 1 year | (6) |
Fabbrini, E. 2010 [40] | USA | Parallel double blind | 9 | 9 | Age (T/C) 43 ± 5/45 ± 3 BMI (T/C)35.8 ± 1.4/37.2 ± 2.0 | ERN 2000 mg/d | P | 16 weeks | (6) |
Sorrentino, S. 2010 [41] | Switzerland | Parallel double blind | 15 | 15 | Age (T/C) 58 ± 11/62 ± 9 BMI (T/C)32 ± 4/34 ± 5 | ERN 1500 mg/d | P | 3 months | (6) |
Hamilton, S. 2010 [42] | Australia | Parallel double blind | 7 | 8 | Age 65 ± 7 BMI 30 ± 5 | Niacin 1500 mg/d | no therapy | 20 weeks | (4) |
Lee, J. 2009 [43] | UK | Parallel double blind | 22 | 29 | Age (T/C) 65 ± 9/65 ± 9 BMI (T/C)31 ± 5/30 ± 5 | NA 1000 mg/d for first 4 weeks, 1500 mg/d for a further 4 weeks, and then 2000 mg/d for the remainder | P | 12 months | (6) |
Jafri, H. 2009 [44] | USA | Parallel double blind | 27 | 27 | Age (T/C) 60 ± 10/57 ± 7 | ERN 1000 mg/d | P | 3 months | (5) |
Cheng, S. 2008 [10] | USA | Cross-over double blind | 33 | 33 | Hemodialysis patients with phosphorus levels > 5.0 mg/dl Age (T/C) 52.6/52.6 | NAM 1500 mg/d | P | 8 weeks | (2) |
Vittone, F. 2007 [45] | USA | Parallel double blind | 80 | 80 | Age (T/C) 54.0 ± 8/53.4 ± 8 BMI (T/C) 29.7 ± 5/29.4 ± 4 | Niacin + simvastatin | P | 3 years | (5) |
Thoenes, M. 2007 [46] | Germany | Parallel double blind | 30 | 15 | Patients with the metabolic syndrome Age (T/C) 34.6 ± 8.1/37.5 ± 9.6 BMI (T/C) 29.7 ± 5/29.4 ± 4 | ERN 1000 mg/d | P | 52 weeks | (3) |
Isley, W. L. 2007 [47] | USA | Parallel | 7 | 7 | Age (T/C) 48 ± 14/58 ± 10 BMI (T/C) 31.7 ± 1.5/30.3 ± 2.1 | Niacin 3000 mg/d | P | 12 weeks | (5) |
Chang, A. 2006 [48] | USA | Cross-over double blind | 15 | 15 | Patients with normal glucose tolerance Age 26 ± 6 BMI 25 ± 3 | NA 2000 mg/d | P | 2 weeks | (1) |
Chang, A. 2006 [48] | USA | Cross-over double blind | 16 | 16 | Patients with normal glucose tolerance Age 70 ± 6 BMI 26 ± 3 | NA 2000 mg/d | P | 2 weeks | (1) |
Chang, A. 2006 [48] | USA | Cross-over double blind | 14 | 14 | Patients with impaired glucose tolerance Age 70 ± 6 BMI 25 ± 3 | NA 2000 mg/d | P | 2 weeks | (4) |
Benjó, A. 2006 [49] | Brazil | Parallel double blind | 11 | 11 | Patients with low HDL-cholesterol BMI (T/C) 27.4 ± 3.7/26.5 ± 3.7 | no-flush niacin 1500 mg/d | P | 3 months | (1) |
Taylor, A. 2004 [50] | USA | Parallel double blind | 78 | 71 | Age (T/C) 67 ± 10/68 ± 10 | ERN 1000 mg/d | P | 12 months | (6) |
Osar, Z. 2004 [51] | Turkey | Parallel | 15 | 15 | Age (T/C) 55 ± 10/59 ± 8 BMI (T/C) 30 ± 5/28 ± 3 | NAM 50 mg/kg | P | 1 month | (4) |
Superko, H. 2004 [52] | USA | Parallel | 60 | 61 | Age (T/C) 53 ± 12/55 ± 12 BMI (T/C) 29 ± 4.4/27 ± 3.6 | ERN 1500 mg/d | P | 14 weeks | (3) |
Superko, H. . 2004 [52] | USA | Parallel | 59 | 61 | Age (T/C) 53 ± 11/55 ± 12 BMI (T/C) 28 ± 5.2/27 ± 3.6 | IRN 3000 mg/d | P | 14 weeks | (3) |
Elam, M. 2000 [53] | USA | Parallel double blind | 49 | 50 | Patients with diabetes Age 67 ± 7 BMI 28 ± 5 | Niacin 3000 mg/d or maximum tolerated dosage | P | 18 weeks | (4) |
Elam, M. 2000 [53] | USA | Parallel double blind | 145 | 150 | Patients without diabetes Age 65 ± 9 BMI 27 ± 5 | Niacin 3000 mg/d or maximum tolerated dosage | P | 18 weeks | (1) |
Keenan, J. 1992 [54] | USA | Parallel double blind | 21 | 26 | Age (Mean) 58.7 | NA 2000–1500 mg/d | P | 24 weeks | (3) |
Keenan, J. . 1992 [54] | USA | Parallel double blind | 26 | 12 | Age (Mean) 39.9 | NA 2000–1500 mg/d | P | 24 weeks | (3) |
Garg, A. 1990 [55] | USA | Cross-over | 13 | 13 | Age 59 ± 1 BMI 29.9 ± 0.7 | NA 4500 mg/d | no therapy | 8 weeks | (4) |
Chase, H. 1990 [56] | USA | Parallel double blind | 18 | 17 | Age (T/C) 12.5 ± 3.7/10.8 ± 3.5 | slow release NAM (100 mg.age (years)−1.day−1 up to a maximum of 1.5 g/day) | P | 12 months | (4) |
Vague, P. 1989 [57] | France | Parallel double blind | 11 | 12 | Age (T/C) 29.8 ± 7.3/26.8 ± 6.2 | NAM 3000 mg/d | P | 9 months | (4) |