- Letters to the Editor
- Open Access
Letter to the editor: healthy alternatives to trans fats
Nutrition & Metabolismvolume 4, Article number: 10 (2007)
Consumption of trans fats is associated with an increase of cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk. To comply with regulatory policies and public health authorities recommendations, trans fats should be replaced in food products. The study by Sundram et al. (Nutrition & Metabolism 2007, 4:3) reporting the effect on CVD risk factors of interesterified fat (IE) and partially hydrogenated soybean oil (PHSO) compared to palm olein (POL) has been critically analyzed. The study design and in particular the composition of the tested fats was not suitable to properly answer the question raised regarding the effect of alternative ingredients to trans fats on plasma lipids. The observed effects are divergent with predicted data derived from the literature model consolidated using the individual results of 60 randomized clinical trials. The results of the study published by Sundram and co-workers have to be considered with awareness.
Diet and health is now recognized to be a critical factor in causing diseases of metabolic origin. Fats in particular are documented to influence the risk of various degenerative diseases. Consumption of monounsaturated trans fatty acids (TFA) has been shown to be associated with increased risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) [1, 2]. Most public health agencies have implemented labeling or ingredient restrictions on trans fats. Alternative ingredients to trans fats are now available in the food supply allowing the reformulation of food products that is mandatory to comply with policies and advices from health authorities. The physical properties and the chemical stability of trans fats were the two major reasons that explained the popularity of this ingredient. The reformulation of food products is difficult because the intrinsic characteristics of the products should be maintained.
Ingredients such as palm olein (POL) produced by physical fractionation of palm fat or interesterified (IE) fats produced from fully hydrogenated vegetable oils could be used as alternative ingredients to trans fats in food products. The major saturated fatty acids present in these fats are palmitic and stearic acids. These two fats are produced using industrial processes flexible enough to obtain the desire physical properties. In a recent paper published in The Journal , Sundram and co-workers reported on the effect on CVD risk factors of partially hydrogenated soybean oil (PHSO), IE and POL. The main comparison was IE and PHSO versus POL. The composition and the physical properties of the three fats compared were not the same. The melting points of the IE and PHSO fats were about 15 to 20°C higher that POL, leading to different applications in the food industry. As a matter of fact, the relative distribution between saturated, monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fatty acids were different for all the fats evaluated. In particular, the content of saturated fatty acid was about 30% higher in the IE fat than in the POL fats; and the content in monounsaturated fatty acids, 2.3 times lower in IE than in POL.
In the frame of the on-going efforts aiming at replacing trans fats in food products, a pertinent strategy would have been to compare, in a double blind fashion, the effects on CVD risk of food items produced from three fats having the same physical properties (i.e. identical melting points). The primary objective (the hypothesis) would have been to compare the nutritional effects of POL and IE to PHSO in order to identify the healthy alternative to trans fat (PHSO) in a controlled design. The experimental conditions used by the investigators were not suitable to answer the question. Indeed, changes in CVD risk factors such as low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C), high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C), total cholesterol and diagnostic ratios were expected from literature data.
It is possible to predict the effects, on plasma lipids, of fats and oils using mathematical models obtained recently, as a result of a large metaanalysis conducted by Mensink and co-workers . The predicted and reported effects of the fats evaluated in the study from Sundram and co-workers  are given in the Figure 1. Confidence intervals (CI) were constructed using metaanalysis coefficients confidence intervals . They represent an estimation of what should be CI and they help defining the credibility of some study results according to metaanalysis results. The effect on HDL-C of IE and PHSO compared to POL measured in the clinical trial compared with the expected effect predicted by the literature model (see Figure 1A). However, the effects on total cholesterol (see Figure 1B), on LDL-C (see Figure 1C) and on the diagnostic ratio total cholesterol to HDL-C (see Figure 1D) differ from the prediction.
Sundram and co-workers  hypothesized that the unexpected effects of IE on the monitored CVD risk factors could be due to the regiospecific distribution of stearic acid on the triacylglycerols (TAG) formed by chemically-catalyzed interesterification. The goal of the interesterification process is to change the physical properties of the starting material: a blend of fats and oils. The melting point of the interesterified fat is usually lower. The analytical method used by Sundram and co-workers  to analyze the test fats is widely used to determine the TAG profile of edible fats and oils. However, this method is not suitable to assess the regiospecific distribution of fatty acids or the molecular species of TAG. Two TAG regio-isomers have the same fatty acids esterified in the Sn-glycerol but not at the same position [e.g. 1,2-dipalmitoyl-3-oleoyl-glycerol (PPO), and 1,3-dipalmitoyl-2-oleoyl-glycerol (POP)]. Reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC) analysis of TAG cannot discriminate TAG regioisomers. The difference between PPO and POP is that the oleic acid is esterified in Sn-1(3) or Sn-2 position on the Sn-glycerol, respectively. These structural data could be assessed by either partial deacylation of TAG using pancreatic lipase or Grignard reagent , by mass-spectrometry  or by NMR .
The neutral effect of stearic acid, compared to oleic acid, on CVD risk factors such as HDL-C, LDL-C and diagnostic ratio has been recently confirmed by Thijssen and Mensink . These recent data are consistent with studies showing that stearic acid compared to oleic acid does not alter plasma lipids [8–10]. The results obtained by Sundram and co-workers  are divergent with the predicted data, derived from the literature model consolidated using the results of 60 randomized clinical trials. The design of the study was not suitable to challenge the hypothesis raised by the investigators. Alternatives to replace trans fats in food products are available. However, the study published by Sundram and co-workers does not allow concluding that palm oil is healthier than interesterified fats.
High-density lipoprotein cholesterol
Low-density lipoprotein cholesterol
Nuclear magnetic spectroscopy
Partially hydrogenated soybean oil
Mozaffarian D, Katan MB, Ascherio A, Stampfer MJ, Willett WC, Ascherio A: Trans fatty acids and cardiovascular disease. N Engl J Med. 2006, 354: 1601-13. 10.1056/NEJMra054035.
Mensink RP, Zock PL, Kester AD, Katan MB: Effects of dietary fatty acids and carbohydrates on the ratio of serum total to HDL cholesterol and on serum lipids and apolipoproteins: a meta-analysis of 60 controlled trials. Am J Clin Nutr. 2003, 77: 1146-55.
Sundram K, Karupaiah T, Hayes K: Stearic acid-rich interesterified fat and trans-rich fat raise the LDL/HDL ratio and plasma glucose relative to palm olein in humans. Nutr Metab. 2007, 4: 3-10.1186/1743-7075-4-3.
Brockerhoff H: Stereospecific Analysis of Triglycerides. Lipids. 1971, 6: 942-956. 10.1007/BF02531179.
List GR, Byrdwell WC, Steidley KR, Adlof RO, Neff WE: Triacylglycerol structure and composition of hydrogenated soybean oil margarine and shortening basestocks. J Agric Food Chem. 2005, 53: 4692-5. 10.1021/jf0404905.
Simova S, Ivanova G, Spassov SL: Alternative NMR method for quantitative determination of acyl positional distribution in triacylglycerols and related compounds. Chem Phys Lipids. 2003, 126: 167-176. 10.1016/j.chemphyslip.2003.08.003.
Thijssen MA, Mensink RP: Small differences in the effects of stearic acid, oleic acid, and linoleic acid on the serum lipoprotein profile of humans. Am J Clin Nutr. 2005, 82: 510-6.
Yu S, Derr J, Etherton T, Kris-Etherton PM: Plasma cholesterolpredictive equations demonstrate that stearic acid is neutral and monounsaturated fatty acids are hypocholesterolemic. Am J Clin Nutr. 1995, 61: 1129-39.
Aro A, Jauhiainen M, Partanen R, Salminen I, Mutanen M: Stearic acid, trans fatty acids, and dairy fat: effects on serum and lipoprotein lipids, apolipoproteins, lipoprotein(a), and lipid transfer proteins in healthy subjects. Am J Clin Nutr. 1997, 65: 1419-26.
Judd JT, Baer DJ, Clevidence BA, Kris-Etherton P, Muesing RA, Iwane M: Dietary cis and trans monounsaturated and saturated FA and plasma lipids and lipoproteins in men. Lipids. 2002, 37: 123-31. 10.1007/s11745-002-0871-9.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Frédéric Destaillats, Julie Moulin and Jean-Baptiste Bezelgues participated equally to the critical analysis of the study published by Sundram and co-workers (3).
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.