- Open Access
Modified Atkins diet in advanced malignancies - final results of a safety and feasibility trial within the Veterans Affairs Pittsburgh Healthcare System
Nutrition & Metabolism volume 13, Article number: 52 (2016)
Dysfunctional mitochondrial processes limit malignant cells ability to use energy from fatty acids and ketones. Animal studies using ketogenic diets for cancer show encouraging results. We tested the diet’s safety and feasibility in cancer patients across a broad variety of solid tumors.
We recruited 17 advanced cancer patients who were not on chemotherapy. They consumed 20 to 40 g of carbohydrates daily with evaluations performed weekly until week 4, then every 4 weeks until 16 weeks. Quality of life questionnaires monitored for tolerability and compliance. Positron emission/computerized tomography was ordered at baseline, 4,8 and 16 weeks. Student t-testing evaluated differences between baseline and last visit scores for quality of life, weight, body mass index, and serum parameters. Correlations between weight loss and serum ketones, glucose, lipids and creatinine were done. Two-tailed unpaired t-testing of the mean weight loss compared responders against non-responders.
Eleven out of seventeen enrolled patients were evaluable. Mean age was 65+/- 11.7 years, weight 203 +/- 4.98 lbs. (92 ± 2.3 kgs.) and previous treatment failures was 1.7, +/- 0.97. All lost significant weight with hematologic, biochemical and lipid tests remaining stable. Quality of life scores slightly improved. At 4,8 and 16 weeks, six (54.5 %), five (45.4 %) and four (36 %) patients were stable or improved. We observed no correlations between serum glucose, ketones or lipids. Clinical response did not correlate with ketosis or glycemia. Responders (stable disease or partial responders) lost statistically more weight than non-responders. Dietary compliance was difficult. Only three patients continued dieting past 16 weeks. Out of these, two patients developed brain metastases and were on steroids. They survived 80 and 116 weeks respectively. The third patient underwent residual tumor resection and has no disease at 131 weeks.
Modified Atkins diets are safe and feasible in advanced cancer. Quality of life was preserved. Patients who lost at least 10 % of their body weight responded the best. Steroid intake affected optimal ketone and glucose levels. Despite this, survival improved in some melanoma and lung cancer patients. Further studies are recommended.
Clinicaltrials.gov NCT01716468. Registered on September 18, 2012
Emerging evidence indicates that ketogenic diets can have therapeutic potential for a broad range of cancers in preclinical animal models and in patients [1–6]. A ketogenic diet is a high-fat low carbohydrate diet that was developed originally to treat refractory epilepsy . KDs create a metabolic state similar to that seen in water-only fasting, where blood glucose levels are reduced and blood ketone bodies (D-β-hydroxybutyrate and acetoacetate) are elevated [7, 8]. Warburg first showed that aerobic fermentation (lactate production in the presence of oxygen) was a hallmark feature of many cancers . This unusual metabolism of tumor cells later became known as the Warburg effect .
Aerobic fermentation was considered a compensatory response to an underlying deficiency in oxidative phosphorylation that could arise from any number of deficiencies in the structure, function or number of mitochondria . Consequently, many tumor cells become addicted to glucose for survival and growth [8, 12, 13]. KDs could therefore put tumor cells under metabolic stress in lowering the availability of glucose and in elevating blood ketone bodies that require functional mitochondria for metabolism [13, 14].
Most normal cells of the body readily metabolize ketone bodies for energy especially when glucose levels become reduced. Indeed, ketone bodies are considered a super fuel since they enhance the ΔG of Adenosine triphosphate ATP hydrolysis while reducing production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) through the co-enzyme Q couple . In contrast to normal cells, the glucose-dependent tumor cells cannot use ketone bodies effectively for energy . Ketone bodies can increase ROS in tumor cells, which can be lethal to these cells . Hence, diets that can target glucose availability while elevating circulating ketone bodies can be a non-toxic therapeutic strategy for managing those tumor cells that express the Warburg effect.
The present study was conducted to evaluate the safety and tolerability of a modified Atkins diet on subjects with advanced cancers. Our secondary objective was to determine whether the diet influenced tumor stability or progression based on changes in fluorodeoxyglucose FDG and PET/CT imaging.
Recruitment and eligibility
This study was reviewed and approved by our hospital’s Independent Review Board (IRB) and listed on - (https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/results/NCT01716468, Ketogenic Diet in Advanced Cancer). Patients were recruited from the Hematology Oncology outpatient clinic of the Pittsburgh Veteran Affairs Healthcare System (Pittsburgh, PA). All patients had advanced solid malignancies that were measurable and avid on FDG PET/CT imaging. None were on chemotherapy at the time of enrollment, and all had good performance status (ECOG 0–2). Exclusion criteria included cases of active gout or kidney stones, active cardiac disease, cachexia, poorly controlled diabetes, liver dysfunction (alanine/aspartate aminotransferase) ALT/AST >3 x upper limits of normal (ULN) if with liver metastasis and > 5 x ULN if no liver metastases), renal failure (serum creatinine of > 2.0 mg/dl) or known brain metastatic disease.
Primary endpoint was safety and feasibility. We investigated quality of life parameters and used a modified Atkins diet as the standard diet for this trial. Patients were allowed 20 to 40 g of carbohydrates per day, during a two-day screening period and were advised on grocery shopping, and menu planning. We restricted consumption of high carbohydrate foods such as cereal, bread, rice, pasta, potatoes and all fruits, but did not restrict calories, protein or fats (Table 1).
Declining performance status, worsening disease, grade 3-weight loss, or inability to maintain at least trace ketosis were criteria for removal. Eligible patients were evaluated at weeks 4, 8, 12 and 16 or until disease progression or voluntarily termination. Patients used version three of the European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire-c30 (EORTC QLQ-c30). Periodic history and physical examinations included measures of height, weight and blood pressure. Blood was drawn (5 cc.) at mid-morning (between 10 AM-12 noon) during the appointed visit days, and was evaluated for a complete blood count, metabolic panel 14, (including electrolytes, uric acid, renal, liver and cholesterol profile), and for serum ketone/beta-hydroxybutyrate determinations. All blood specimens were processed in the clinical pathology laboratory (Pittsburgh VA Healthcare System) using 0.4 cc in Beckman DXC800 and DXH800 chemistry and cell hematology analyzers. Patients were monitored for adverse effects and diet tolerability. Tumors were evaluated using PET /CT for heat imaging and RECIST version 1.1 criteria for size.
PET/CT scanning technique
All patients with fasting blood glucose levels from 60 to 180 mg/dl were included in the study group. The patients received between 10–15 mCi of FDG intravenously, (~0.15 mCi/kg BW). An in-vivo incubation time of 60 min was allowed for optimal FDG accumulation to be seen in the tumor’s hypermetabolic areas. CT-PET imaging was performed on a Philips-Gemini TF PET scanner. Time-of-Flight 3-D acquisition involved: 50 % bed position overlap with acquisition time of 1.75 min to 2.5 min per bed position. Low dose CT scans and PET scans were obtained with standard established protocol parameters from skull base to thigh level and/or whole body as needed. Acquired CT and PET images were processed to generate 3-plane images, MIP images, and co-registered series. The studies were interpreted and compared to prior evaluations using a Philips EBW-PET workstation. Tumor size was evaluated in two dimensions on axial images. Standardized uptake values (SUV) were recorded for each area and were compared to the same area in subsequent studies. Liver SUV near the falciform ligament was used as internal control.
Statistical and graphical analysis
The EORTC QLQ-c30 was used to assess quality of life (QOL) scores. Scores were compiled and a line graph was created depicting QOL over specific time points (baseline, and at weeks 4, 8 and 16) Fig. 2. The student t-test was used to evaluate the significance of differences between baseline scores and last visit scores for quality of life QOL, body weights, and body mass index (BMI). Comparisons between baseline and last visit values were also evaluated for the following blood markers: total cholesterol, the high and low density lipoproteins (HDL and LDL), triglycerides, fasting glucose, serum creatinine, white blood cell count (WBC), uric acid, albumin, and serum b-hydroxybutyrate (βOHB). Correlations were evaluated between net body weight loss and the following serum markers: serum beta-hydroxybutyrate/ketone levels, glucose, and creatinine. Correlations were also calculated between serum glucose and βOHB and between glucose versus total, HDL, LDL cholesterol and triglycerides. Two-tailed unpaired t-testing of the mean weight loss in responders versus non-responders (SD or PR) was performed using IBM SPSS Statistics Version 21 software. Testing was also performed using values of ketone βOHB and glucose levels. SUV lesion values of responders were compared with the values from non-responders.
Recruitment and initial screening process
Over 300 prospective candidates for the study were screened by phone, email, and in person. All 17 of the accepted candidates were Caucasian males, and were recruited from the Pittsburgh Veteran Affairs Hematology and Oncology outpatient clinic. The average age was 65 with a median age of 64 (42–87 years). Demographics are listed under Table 2. All patients were overweight (203 ± 4.98 lbs. or 92 ± 2.3 kgs.) and had a mean body mass index (BMI) of 29.46 ± 5. Tumor histology was diverse and included adenocarcinoma (biliary, prostate, colon, pancreas-2, lung; 6 patients), squamous cell carcinoma (lung, parotid, glottis; 4 patients), malignant melanoma (3 patients), brain tumors (glioblastoma and astrocytoma; 1 patient each), papillary thyroid carcinoma (1 patient), and hepatocellular carcinoma (1 patient). All malignancies were advanced, metastatic, and unresectable. All but three were pretreated. The mean number of previous treatment failures was 1.7. Three patients were chemo-naïve (patients 4, 15 and 17) and declined chemotherapy.
Screen failures and dietary adherence: Screen failures occurred in 6/17 (35 %) patients. Patient #1 withdrew after two weeks due to personal issues. Patients # 2, #14, and #15 withdrew within one week due to deteriorating performance status unrelated to the diet. Patient #2 was an insulin dependent diabetic, but no longer required insulin after only 2 days of dieting. Patient #11 did not qualify due to absence of hyper-metabolic activity on his PET CT scan. Patient # 16 changed his mind regarding participation in the study. The remaining 11/17 patients (65 %) had a mean age of 65 ± 11.7 years, weight 203 ± 4.98 lbs. These eleven proceeded with the trial, completing between 4 to 16 weeks of dieting without significant adverse effects. Six patients (35 %) maintained the diet for 8 weeks and four patients (23 %) (# 4,9,12,17) completed 16 weeks. Of these four, only three (# 4,9 and 12) successfully dieted beyond 16 weeks. One patient (# 4) remained very active until he died at 80 weeks, another patient (#9) who also remained active died suddenly at 116 weeks. The third patient (#12) remains alive without evidence of disease at 131 weeks.
No significant adverse effects were observed in any of treated patients. Indeed, a slight trend for improved quality of life was noted for most patients on the diet. Weight loss was observed in 8/11 patients (73 %). Hyperuricemia was observed in 7/11 patients (64 %), and hyperlipidemia in 2/11 patients (18). Pedal edema, anemia, halitosis, pruritus, hypoglycemia, hyperkalemia, hypokalemia, hypomagnesemia, fatigue and flu like symptoms were seen in 2/11 patients (18 %). Although 2 patients reported halitosis, only one was determined to be actually with ketone breath (Table 3).
Effect on weight, body mass index (BMI), and blood pressure
A mean weight loss of 3.2 lb. (1.5 kgs.) wt. loss (-1.5 %), median 3.5 SD 4.92, range 17;–11 to +6 lb. (-5 kg. to + 2.7 kg) was observed after only 2–3 days of dieting. Weight loss was consistent during the study and by week 16, subjects had lost 27 lbs. ± 13.3 or 12.3 ± 6.0 kgs. (-13 %) (Table 3, Fig. 1). Weight loss for all subjects was 16.4 ± 12.8 lbs (7.5 ± 5.8 kgs.) and highly significantly reduced compared to baseline values (P < 0.000108) Table 4. Three patients dieted for 16 weeks and beyond with a median percent weight loss of 10.19 % (range 6.91–17.83). BMI was also significantly decreased (P < 0.0004) compared to baseline values with a mean difference of 2.669 ± 1.99, (Fig. 1 : Body mass index and weight changes over time) (Table 4).
Hematology and blood chemistries, ketones, lipids: baseline compared to last visit values
No significant differences were seen between initial values and last visit values for biochemical and hematologic parameters (Table 5). Blood glucose values were similar at the start and at the end of the study with mean values of 92.8 ± 30 mg/dl (5.2 mM). One patient (#2) was an insulin-dependent type 2 diabetic and experienced a 100 % decrease in insulin requirements after two days on the diet and remained asymptomatic.
Lipid profiles of almost all patients (94 %) remained stable throughout and did not change significantly from baseline to last visit. Total cholesterol (p = 0.819), LDL cholesterol (p = 0.772), HDL (p = 0.0612), triglyceride (p = 0.674) values at the last visit did not significantly change from baseline. Although the majority of the patients had no change in their lipid profiles, patient #12 started the trial with an elevated LDL value of 191 mg/dl, which decreased to 112 mg/dl by week 16 without using lipid lowering medication. The reverse was seen with patient # 9. This patient started with a fasting LDL of 85 mg/dl and had an LDL level of 178 by week 16, necessitating initiation of a statin medication. Blood urea nitrogen (BUN)/creatinine ratios (p = 0.108), serum creatinine (p = 0.314), albumin (p = 0.698), and uric acid levels (p = 0.565) all remained stable. White blood cell counts at baseline did not significantly differ with last visit values. Baseline PET/CT mean calculated SUV values for all lesions compared to week 4 and 8 values remained unchanged (p = 0.433 and p = 0.872 respectively). Mean SUV baseline values compared to last visit SUV also did not differ (p =0.77) There were no statistical difference systolic (p = 0.394) and diastolic (p = 0.43) blood pressure readings at baseline versus last visit (Table 5).
The Glucose/Ketone Index (GKI) is a ratio of the glucose (mmol) over beta-hydroxybuytrate levels (mmol) at any given time . As levels of blood glucose decline, the blood levels of ketone bodies should rise, intersecting at a certain point beyond which one enters the “therapeutic zone”. This is when tumor growth is expected to slow or cease. None of the patients in this study reached GKI values predicted for therapeutic benefit against cancer (<1.0). Elevated β − OHB levels were observed in all patients within the first two days of dieting. In the first two days of dieting, 7 out of 10 patients (70 %) easily achieved a ketosis levels of 3-10 mg/dl or 0.3–1.0 mM, and only 2 were non-ketotic. Patients (# 5, 6, 7, 12) achieved βOHB levels ranging from 0.3 to 4.1 mM, while the mean βOHB level was less than 0.3 mM in the other patients. Patient 13 had some difficulty with menu planning and was removed from the trial when he progressed at 4 weeks, achieving only 2 weeks of ketosis out of 4. Once ketosis was achieved, mean ketone levels remained unchanged till the last visit compared to the first positive baseline (p = 0.785). After only two days of fasting the mean βOHB level rose to about 11.3 mg/dl (1.1 mM) with patients 5,6,7,8 and 12 having registered serum ketosis of over 19 mg/dl or 1.83 mM (median 24, range 19–26 mg/dl or 1.83 mMol to 2.5 mM). With the exception of patient #8, all the other patients maintained this level of ketosis for the first 4 weeks. As the study progressed, a drop in serum ketone levels was seen. The mean at week 4 was 12.08 mg/dl ± 10, and declined to 7.4 mg/dl ± 4.81, and 6.17 mg/dl ±7.99 at weeks 8 and 16, respectively. This decrease in mean βOHB was not statistically significant (p = 0.875) indicating generally good compliance and ability to maintain ketosis with the passage of time. Note, that when converted to millimoles, the achieved values of 7 eligible patients (63 %) ranged between 0.28 mM to 0.96 mM ketones with 4 patients (36 %) achieving values between 0.96 to 4.13 mM.
Correlations between weight loss and serum chemistries
Non-significant differences were seen with net weight loss (lbs.) versus βOHB ketones (p = 0.325, p = 0.992, p = 0.897), glucose (p = 0.95, p = 0.295, p = 0156), or creatinine (p = 0.425, p = 0.441, p = 0.377) at weeks 4, 8, and 16 (Table 6).
Correlations between serum glucose and chemistries
At 4 and 8 weeks, no significant correlations were found between serum glucose versus percent (%) weight loss, ketone levels, triglycerides (TG), low density lipoprotein (LDL), high density lipoprotein (HDL), and total cholesterol (Table 7).
Quality of life parameters
Patients who continued on the diet for 4 weeks or more (n = 6) reported stable well-being and symptomatology at end of their trial with no statistically significant deterioration in quality of life scores: social (p = 0.179), physical (p = 0.225), emotional (p = 0.313), financial difficulties (p = 0.347), cognitive (p = 0.195) and role (p = 0.859) functioning. There was also no significant worsening of fatigue (p = 1.00), insomnia (p = 0.798), appetite (p = 0.269), constipation (p = 0.343), diarrhea (p = 0.347), or pain (p = 0.262).
Patients reported some improvement of cognitive functioning, dyspnea, constipation, diarrhea and insomnia. At 4 weeks there was a slight increase in the fatigue score but this also improved by 8 and 16 weeks (Fig. 2: Quality of Life parameters).
Responders versus non-responders
Two-tailed unpaired t testing of the mean weight loss in non-responders versus responders was performed using SPSS (Statistical Package for the Social Sciences) and Graphpad software 2015. The percentage body weight loss was significantly greater in the responders (stable disease SD or partial response PR) (p = 0.03, SD ± 2.28) than in the non-responders. No differences were seen between responders and non-responders in terms of serum ketone values (p = 0.67), fasting glucose (p = 0.1905), or mean calculated SUV (p = 0.7714).
Effect on the tumor
Due the low patient number, statistical analysis of the diet’s effect on tumor growth could not be performed. At the 4-week assessment, five (45 %) progressed (patients 3, 5, 6,10,13) based on RECIST 1.1 criteria and 6 (54.5 %), (patients 4,7,8,9,12,17) had stable or partially improved disease. One patient (# 5) had stable disease (decreased 3.9 %) in his target lesions at week 4 and achieved excellent ketosis (+3), but was considered progressed and had to be removed from the trial due to a newly discovered brain metastasis. Whether it was present at the beginning of the trial or was a new lesion was undetermined since he did not have baseline head scans. All the other six stable patients were allowed to diet until 8 weeks. At 8 weeks, one patient (# 7) had progressive disease, but five patients remained stable (# 4, 8, 9,12, 17) or with diminished disease. Patient # 8 withdrew voluntarily, but 4 patients (# 4, 9, 12, and 17) continued dieting until 16 weeks. At 16 weeks, four patients (36 % of total, 100 % of 8th week responders) had stable disease (# 12, 16, 17) or reduced disease symptoms (# 9) at the end of their trial participation (Table 8).
All four patients who continued the diet past 16 weeks were followed in the outpatient clinic and by telephone interview. One out of the four, suffered from a case of stage IV lung cancer. The remaining three patients all had stage IV malignant melanoma, one of whom (# 12) was BRAF V600 positive.
The first 16-week patient (# 4), an 87-year-old male with diffuse multi-organ involved Stage IV melanoma, refused all forms of chemotherapy, but agreed to enroll in the modified Atkins diet trial. At 4 weeks of dieting he felt energetic and remained asymptomatic. His 4-week PET/CT scan showed mixed findings with several areas showing decreased as well as increased FDG activity. The overall clinical picture for this patient showed improved disease. By 8 and 16 weeks his disease remained stable. After 16 weeks he dieted with occasional lapses in ketosis. He developed brain metastases after 36 weeks from enrollment and was treated with steroids and gamma knife irradiation. He had difficulty maintaining ketosis but maintained his weight and active lifestyle while pain free until a few weeks before his death at age 88, marking 80 weeks from his date of enrollment.
Our second patient, (# 9), was a 62 year old male with stage IV melanoma who completed the trial at 16 weeks with stable disease. Intermittently he would be less strict with the diet and lapse out of ketosis. He had tried and progressed through ipilimumab, pembrolizumab, three rounds of transhepatic chemoembolization, two rounds of oral Temozolomide, and gamma knife radiation to his brain metastases. During the last year of his life he received no chemotherapy other than gamma knife brain irradiation plus a month of Temozolomide, and followed the ketogenic diet as his main treatment course. He was hospitalized for new onset seizures and subsequently placed on systemic steroids. Despite this he mostly remained on the ketogenic diet but because of the hyperglycemic effects of the steroids was unable to achieve the target glucose ketone index GKI. His performance status however remained excellent and he lived a total of 116 weeks from diet initiation, and nearly three years from his initial diagnosis of stage four melanoma.
Our third patient, a 42-year old male with stage IV BRAF V600 positive, Vemurafenib intolerant metastatic melanoma (patient 12), completed 16 weeks of the trial with stable disease but had persistently PET positive left axillary nodes which had not changed in size but did have some partial decrease in hypermetabolic activity while on the diet. He underwent complete surgical removal of his persistent bulky metastatic axillary nodes in July 2014 and had no adjuvant chemotherapy or radiation. He followed the modified ketogenic diet for another year after surgery and then reverted back to a standard diet at around 80 weeks. He had no evidence of disease on PET/CT scan and remained alive and well at 131 weeks.
The fourth patient, patient 17, an 84 year old with chemo-naive stage IV squamous cell lung carcinoma dieted until 16 weeks and finished the trial with stable disease while achieving excellent ketosis (+2). However, after completing the trial at week 16, he decided to revert back to low carbohydrate, non-ketotic diet. He failed to follow up for repeat imaging and died at 40 weeks.
This trial showed that a modified ketogenic diet was well tolerated in cancer patients with a broad variety of solid tumors. Adverse effects were minimal and none were serious. These findings are therefore consistent with other studies that treated brain cancer patients with ketogenic diets [4, 5, 11, 14, 16, 17, 18] Concerns about weight loss and malnutrition were one of the initial worries as was the possibility of deleterious effects on one’s lipid profile and quality of life. Most of our patients were either overweight (7 pts. or 42 % with BMI 25–29.9) or obese (7 or 42 % with BMI over 30) at enrolment and only 3 had normal (18 % with BMI 18.5–24.9) weight upon entering the trial. Surprisingly, weight loss did not show significant correlations with ketone levels, glucose or other hematologic or electrolyte measurements. Weight loss was seen in all patients and was significant (p = 0.0001). The patients who responded with either stable disease or partial responses had significantly more weight loss (p = 0.01) than those patients who progressed. Weight loss percentage of at least 10 % or more was seen in the responders. This weight loss was not like the cachectic weight loss that we see in cancer patients in their terminal stages because our patients maintained their quality of life scores and in some cases even improved upon them.
There was also some concern that the renal function might worsen with this diet and that diabetics might not be able to tolerate it. Renal function as well as hematologic parameters remained stable. One patient (patient 4) who began with some renal insufficiency improved his serum creatinine after 4 weeks while another patient with diabetes (patient 2) who was on insulin became insulin free within days.
Previous studies examined the effects of this diet on small patient numbers. These studies were also of short duration 4-12 weeks. We wanted to improve on this by allowing our patients to diet for a longer period of time (16 weeks). In addition we allowed long-term follow up after the 16-week period was completed. We followed four patients beyond 16 weeks and found that one (patient 17) reverted back to a standard diet within days while the other two (patients 4 and 12) continued to follow the diet without any subsequent chemotherapy or radiation, remaining in stable status for as long as 80 and 131 weeks.
Combining the diet with chemotherapy and/or radiation appears feasible. One patient (patient 9) subsequently tried a short course (one month) of oral chemotherapy and had also benefitted from invasive radiology as well as radio surgical interventions.
In the VM-M3 glioblastoma model, a low GKI is related to decreased invasion, proliferation and angiogenesis . The study protocol was created prior to the introduction of the GKI and our patients did not have the benefit of frequent home glucose and ketone monitoring hence the collected in-hospital glucose and ketone readings may not be truly reflective of their actual glucose ketone indices. Discrepancies in blood draw timing and patient compliance with timing of clinic visits may have also affected some of our glucose values. Glucose ketone indices (GKI) were calculated and we found that although no patient met the targeted range of GKI, some still derived benefit, significantly outliving their estimated lifespans. One patient (patient #9) who had a good response and survived until 116 weeks, experienced persistent “ketone breath” despite achieving low βHOB ketone readings. It is possible that he achieved adequate therapeutic levels that somehow escaped detection [20, 21].
We wanted to attract a diverse population of patients, and standardize all evaluations. The small number of recruited patients limited our trial, and our recruitment was uniformly Caucasian male even though we did not exclude diverse racial types nor exclude females. Had we expanded our trial to another year’s length we perhaps could have attracted a more diverse patient sample.
One previous study had recruited patients from different institutions each with their own dietician, hence dietary instruction was not standardized across the board . Blood work/scans were sent to separate laboratories and imaging facilities, possibly causing variations in data interpretations. We hoped to improve on this by recruiting all our subjects from a single institution and uniformly obtained all our testing from our inpatient hospital laboratory. Our images were read by a dedicated nuclear radiologist as well as obtained via the same dedicated PET/ CT scanner. Travel time was also an issue. Most of our patients lived a long distance from our hospital (some > 3 h away) which made recruitment difficult given the travel time and frequency of visits. Majority of the interested patients who lived locally did not qualify, as they were not US veterans, one reason for inclusion.
We chose to scan with PET/CT imaging as early as 4 weeks. Previous studies show that PET/CT scans can detect partial responses to chemotherapy as early as after one cycle . In the future we feel that an 8 week PET/CT scan instead of four will be more useful as some tumors may actually be experiencing a tumor flare prior to shrinkage. We also excluded patients with brain metastases because we expected poorer performance statuses. In hindsight it could have been better to include them. Many of these patients actually do well enough to last through a short dietary course without any deleterious effects.
Not all of our patients responded to the KD. Previous work on identifying characteristics that would predict for response have studied the role of defective OXPHOS enzymes [11, 22]. The metabolic switch from oxidative phosphorylation to non-oxidative fermentation is thought to be related to upregulation of transketolase TKTL-1 protein expression which was correlated with invasive tumors [23, 24]. Identification of ketolytic and glycolytic enzyme overexpression in malignancies may help stratify those patients with low enzyme expression and accordingly should respond more favorably to the KD [11, 24].
Most of our patients were overweight and were likely to be leptin resistant and as a result have high body leptin levels. Leptin is a pro-angiogenic metabolic hormone which is secreted by adipose tissue. It sends satiety signals to the hypothalamus in response to caloric intake. Ghrelin is the opposing hormone which increases our appetite. Intake of sucrose during the fasting state results in a rise in serum leptin. However, over consumption of foods high in sucrose leads to a blunted leptin response, which leads to higher serum leptin levels [25, 26]. Unlike leptin, ghrelin secretion is suppressed by intake of both sucrose and fats. Leptin secretion is therefore probably linked to sucrose rather than fat metabolism. Increased leptin levels are associated with faster tumor growth in animal studies . In humans, particularly obese individuals have higher leptin levels and correspondingly have higher rates of human cancers. A study of melanoma patients found significantly higher leptin levels in those with positive sentinel node biopsies . The patients who responded with stable or improved disease lost more percentage weight, and by doing so decreased the body leptin and consequently slowed down angiogenesis.
The effect of the diet on lifespan cannot be adequately examined here due to the low number of subjects enrolled and the diverse nature of each patient’s individual tumors. However out of the four patients who did well until 16 weeks, three had a diagnosis of melanoma and all three not only went beyond 16 weeks of dieting but also significantly exceeded their expected lifespans (typically only 3 months). One remains alive and free of disease at 121 weeks. Due to variations in timing of blood draws, the reported ketone levels of these patients were not significantly elevated and none achieved the target glucose ketone index, although two did report significant halitosis which could mean that their recorded ketone levels may be underestimating their true average daily [20, 21] Whether patients with malignant melanomas have intrinsic characteristics making them more responsive to the ketogenic diet over other tumor types remains to be investigated further.
The modified Atkins diet is well tolerated by patients with advanced cancer. Hematologic parameters, serum cholesterol, renal function and lipid levels remained stable. There was improvement in insulin requirements and renal function in a few patients. Quality of life measures remained stable and the diet was simple to initiate and implement. For some, the adherence to the diet remained excellent at one year and beyond. It is possible that therapeutic efficacy could be greater in future studies where patients can enter the predicted GKI zone. In this study, ideal target glucose and ketone values may have been reached but were not accurately recorded due to variations in patient compliance with blood draw timing and fasting states. The diet might help improve quality and of life and enhance tumor response to chemotherapy in cancer patients. Looking forward, the incorporation of immunohistochemical staining for ketolytic/glycolytic enzymes and biomarkers (i.e. leptin, insulin) and their role in tailoring metabolic cancer management merits further study. Notably, melanoma patients represented the three who benefitted most from this study. Future studies should investigate the modified Atkins diet MAD or the ketogenic diet KD and their potential benefits to this type of cancer.
ALT, alanine transaminase; ATP, Adenosine triphosphate; BMI, body mass index; BP, blood pressure; BUN, blood urea nitrogen; ECOG, Eastern Cooperative Group; EORTC, European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer; FDG, Fluorodeoxyglucose; GKI, glucose ketone index; HDL, high density lipoprotein; IRB, institutional review board, KD, ketogenic diet; LDL, low density lipoprotein; OXPHOS, oxidative phosphorylation; PET/CT, positron emission tomograpghy/computerized tomography; PR, partial response; QOL, quality of life; ROS, Reactive oxygen species; SD, stable disease; SUV, Standardized uptake units; TG, triglycerides; TKTL, transketolase; βOHB, beta hydroxybutyrate
Abdelwahab MG, Fenton KE, Preul MC, et al. The ketogenic diet is an effective adjuvant to radiation therapy for the treatment of malignant glioma. PLoS One. 2012;7(5). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0036197.
Fine EJ, Segal-Isaacson CJ, Feinman RD, et al. Targeting insulin inhibition as a metabolic therapy in advanced cancer: A pilot safety and feasibility dietary trial in 10 patients. Nutrition. 2012;28(10):1028–35. doi:10.1016/j.nut.2012.05.001.
Schmidt M, Pfetzer N, Schwab M, Strauss I, Kammerer U. Effects of a ketogenic diet on the quality of life in 16 patients with advanced cancer: A pilot trial. Nutr Metab (Lond). 2011;8(1):54. doi:10.1186/1743-7075-8-54.
Nebeling LC, Miraldi F, Shurin SB, Lerner E. Effects of a Ketogenic Diet on Tumor Metabolism and Nutritional Status in Pediatric Oncology Patients: Two Case Reports. J Am Coll Nutr. 1995;14:202–8. doi:10.1080/07315724.1995.10718495.
Zuccoli G, Marcello N, Pisanello A, et al. Metabolic management of glioblastoma multiforme using standard therapy together with a restricted ketogenic diet: Case Report. Nutr Metab (Lond). 2010;7:33. doi:10.1186/1743-7075-7-33.
Poff AM, Ari C, Arnold P, Seyfried TN, D’Agostino DP. Ketone supplementation decreases tumor cell viability and prolongs survival of mice with metastatic cancer. Int J Cancer. 2014;135(7). doi:10.1002/ijc.28809.
Freeman JM, Kossoff EH, Hartman AL. The ketogenic diet: one decade later. Pediatrics. 2007;119(3):535–43. doi:10.1542/peds.2006-2447.
Cahill GF. Fuel metabolism in starvation. Annu Rev Nutr. 2006;26:1–22. doi:10.1146/annurev.nutr.26.061505.111258.
Warburg O. Injuring of Respiration the Origin of Cancer Cells. Science (80-). 1956;123(3191):309–14. doi:10.1126/science.123.3191.309.
Racker E, Spector M. Warburg effect revisited: merger of biochemistry and molecular biology. Science (80-). 1981;213(4505):303–7. doi:10.1126/science.6264596.
Chang HT, Olson LK, Schwartz KA. Ketolytic and glycolytic enzymatic expression profiles in malignant gliomas: implication for ketogenic diet therapy. Nutr Metab (Lond). 2013;10(1):47. doi:10.1186/1743-7075-10-47.
Shaw RJ. Glucose metabolism and cancer. Curr Opin Cell Biol. 2006;18(6):598–608. doi:10.1016/j.ceb.2006.10.005. S0955-0674(06)00158-X [pii].
Meidenbauer JJ, Mukherjee P, Seyfried TN. The glucose ketone index calculator: a simple tool to monitor therapeutic efficacy for metabolic management of brain cancer. Nutr Metab (Lond). 2015;12(1):12. doi:10.1186/s12986-015-0009-2.
Seyfried TN, Kiebish M. a, Marsh J, Shelton LM, Huysentruyt LC, Mukherjee P. Metabolic management of brain cancer. Biochim Biophys Acta. 2011;1807(6):577–94. doi:10.1016/j.bbabio.2010.08.009.
Veech RL. The therapeutic implications of ketone bodies: The effects of ketone bodies in pathological conditions: Ketosis, ketogenic diet, redox states, insulin resistance, and mitochondrial metabolism. Prostaglandins Leukot Essent Fat Acids. 2004;70(3):309–19. doi:10.1016/j.plefa.2003.09.007.
Rieger J, Bähr O, Maurer GD, et al. ERGO: a pilot study of ketogenic diet in recurrent glioblastoma. Int J Oncol. 2014;44(6):1843–52. doi:10.3892/ijo.2014.2382.
Scheck AC, Abdelwahab MG, Fenton KE, Stafford P. The ketogenic diet for the treatment of glioma: Insights from genetic profiling. Epilepsy Res. 2012;100(3):327–37. doi:10.1016/j.eplepsyres.2011.09.022.
Rieger J, Baehr O, Hattingen E, et al. The ERGO trial: A pilot study of a ketogenic diet in patients with recurrent glioblastoma. J Clin Oncol (Meeting Abstr. 2010;28(15_suppl):e12532 -. http://meeting.ascopubs.org/cgi/content/abstract/28/15_suppl/e12532. Accessed 20 Oct 2015.
Poff AM, Ward N, Seyfried TN, Arnold P, D’Agostino DP. Non-Toxic Metabolic Management of Metastatic Cancer in VM Mice: Novel Combination of Ketogenic Diet, Ketone Supplementation, and Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy. PLoS One. 2015;10(6):e0127407. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0127407.
Musa-Veloso K, Likhodii SS, Rarama E, et al. Breath acetone predicts plasma ketone bodies in children with epilepsy on a ketogenic diet. Nutrition. 2006;22(1):1–8. doi:10.1016/j.nut.2005.04.008.
Musa-Veloso K. Non-invasive detection of ketosis and its application in refractory epilepsy. Prostaglandins Leukot Essent Fat Acids. 2004;70(3):329–35. doi:10.1016/j.plefa.2003.08.025.
Mathupala SP, Ko YH, Pedersen PL. Hexokinase II: cancer’s double-edged sword acting as both facilitator and gatekeeper of malignancy when bound to mitochondria. Oncogene. 2006;25(34):4777–86. doi:10.1038/sj.onc.1209603.
Langbein S, Zerilli M. zur Hausen A, et al. Expression of transketolase TKTL1 predicts colon and urothelial cancer patient survival: Warburg effect reinterpreted. Br J Cancer. 2006;94(4):578–85. doi:10.1038/sj.bjc.6602962.
Lange CA, Tisch-Rottensteiner J, Böhringer D, Martin G, Schwartzkopff J, Auw-Haedrich C. Enhanced TKTL1 expression in malignant tumors of the ocular adnexa predicts clinical outcome. Ophthalmology. 2012;119(9):1924–9. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2012.03.037.
Lindqvist A, De La Cour CD, Stegmark A, Håkanson R, Erlanson-Albertsson C. Overeating of palatable food is associated with blunted leptin and ghrelin responses. Regul Pept. 2005;130(3):123–32. doi:10.1016/j.regpep.2005.05.002.
Park J, Scherer PE. Leptin and cancer: From cancer stem cells to metastasis. Endocr Relat Cancer. 2011;18(4). doi:10.1530/ERC-11-0163.
Amjadi F, Javanmard SH, Zarkesh-Esfahani H, Khazaei M, Narimani M. Leptin promotes melanoma tumor growth in mice related to increasing circulating endothelial progenitor cells numbers and plasma NO production. J Exp Clin Cancer Res. 2011;30(1):21. doi:10.1186/1756-9966-30-21.
Oba J, Chattopadhyay C, Gershenwald JE, Johnson MM, Ellerhorst JA, Grimm EA. A role for elevated leptin, independent of obesity, in the progression of melanoma. Cancer Res. 2015;75(14). http://cancerres.aacrjournals.org/content/75/14_Supplement/A32?cited-by=yes&legid=canres;7. Accessed 20 Oct 2015.
Tammy Cobaugh for her help in drafting the initial trial protocol; Samantha Bonant, Alanna Caffas and and Sharlene Wylie for research assistance Becky Englert RN, Lynn Marmarelli RN and Pamela Malicki RN for patient recruitment and followup; Mary Kay Winkelman for her secretarial contribution; Joseph Mikolic for statistical analysis; Mariam Shalaby for proofreading and technical support. I am grateful to the Veterans Research Foundation of Pittsburgh for their overall support and confidence in this project. I would like to thank Dr. Thomas Seyfried, Professor of Biology at Boston College, for his critical comments and valuable feedback during the editing and revision of the final manuscript.
No external funding other than voluntary individual departmental laboratory and nursing support was utilized in this study.
Availability of data and material
Data sets are deposited under the care of the Veterans Affairs Research Institute, Pittsburgh VA Healthcare System. The datasets during and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
JTS, JC and RC conceived and designed the protocol. Administrative support-AL and VP. Data collection and assembly-AL, VP, DG, KE, JC, JTS, RS. Dietary guidance-JC and KE. Data analysis and interpretation-JTS, JC, RS. Recruitment and follow up of study patients- AL, VP, DG, KE, JTS, JC. All authors reviewed and approved the manuscript.
JTS, AL and VP are attending physicians in the Hematology Oncology department of the VA Pittsburgh Healthcare system. They all hold clinical assistant professor faculty positions at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine. JTS is the principal investigator and JC is the main research coordinator for this investigator initiated study. VP is oncology section chief. AL is director of clinical trials. RS is chief of Nuclear Medicine at the Pittsburgh VA Medical Center. DG is our clinical oncology nurse and KD is our registered ketogenic dietician.
The authors declare that they haveno competing interests.
Consent for publication
Informed consent to participate in this study as well as for future publication was obtained from all participants.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This study was approved by the Veteran Affairs Institutional review board and ethics committee.
An erratum to this article can be found at http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s12986-016-0120-z.
About this article
Cite this article
Tan-Shalaby, J.L., Carrick, J., Edinger, K. et al. Modified Atkins diet in advanced malignancies - final results of a safety and feasibility trial within the Veterans Affairs Pittsburgh Healthcare System. Nutr Metab (Lond) 13, 52 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12986-016-0113-y
- Standardize Uptake Value
- Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma
- Ketone Body
- Gamma Knife
- Ketogenic Diet